Rustpot
M Frame Lover
So you don't see any difference between what happened and the other two scenarios?It was Oakley's problem, and Oakley's screwup to allow it to happen. Go after the people that seemingly illegally generated or stole the codes, I'm all for it. To punish customers for it is absolutely ridiculous. To go so far as banning someone from ever purchasing from them at full price is incredibly short-sighted and is nothing but them taking out their frustrations on the wrong people. I, for one, will be ending any direct purchases from them for quite some time.
For those lecturing people about using discount codes, please interject in every thread about people sharing bounce back rewards or F&F discounts as well (oh wait, some are the same people that have done it). After all, they are being used by people other than the person intended for. And as Brett mentions, be sure to return all the display cases and other non-retail items in your collections as well.
Cases are thrown out. Non-brand stores call up reps to return the cases and get told to throw them out if they get a response at all. Or a rep collects a storage locker full, moves to another job, and isn't asked to return all of the cases. There can be arguments made about abandoned property, public domain, etc. If Oakley cared they would police it, but they don't. And then some guy shows up to Jim Jannard's place with a truckload of cases, POP material, never-released prototypes, lunches with company big wigs and nothing is said. I think it's safe to say Oakley doesn't care.
And the F&F codes or other rewards codes? Again, if you don't see the difference between these 60% codes being bought, and individuals bartering their earned discounts or directly gifted codes (that anyone is eligible for).... well I can't help you there. Especially when an Oakley employee comes on the board and asks people to email him to get more codes.
Do I think banning all full-price purchases of code users is silly? Yes. Do I understand why people are upset their bouncebacks or F&F codes don't work after they used a sketchy code? Nope.